Psychology study offers messaging roadmap for changing attitudes on environmental issues and policies
by New York University
Credit: CC0 Public Domain Conservatives and liberals may be at odds in their views on environmental issues, but a new psychology study shows that framing the need to address climate change as patriotic and as necessary to preserve the American “way of life” can increase belief in climate change and support for pro-environmental policies among both groups.
“Framing climate change action as a way to protect and preserve patriotic values and familiar ways of life can improve climate awareness and motivate action across the American political spectrum,” says Katherine Mason, a New York University doctoral student and the lead author of the study , which appears in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences ( PNAS ).
“This approach encourages people to see climate action as a way to celebrate and sustain cherished cultural traditions, rather than having to relinquish or replace them.”
The findings, which stem from an experiment involving 50,000 participants across 60 countries, showed such messaging had similar, though smaller, effects among liberals in some nations, including France and Chile, and among conservatives in Israel and Chile. However, it backfired among conservatives in other nations—notably, Belgium, Germany, and Russia.
Overall, the results are at odds with much of today’s pro-environment messaging, which often centers on doomsday scenarios, overhauling our socioeconomic system, or radically altering our consumption habits.
“It is crucial to avoid triggering…existential threats, insofar as these can motivate system defensiveness and backlash against pro-environmental initiatives,” write the authors, who also included John Jost, a professor in NYU’s Department of Psychology, and Madalina Vlasceanu, an NYU assistant professor at the time of the study and now at Stanford University.
In the PNAS study, participants were informed they would be asked to read some information, report on their beliefs and behaviors, and write a small paragraph.
To ensure a common understanding of climate change, they were given the following definition: “Climate change is the phenomenon describing the fact that the world’s average temperature has been increasing over the past 150 years and will likely be increasing more in the future.”
Participants assigned to the control condition then read a literary passage from Charles Dickens’ 1861 novel “Great Expectations,” which made no references to the climate.
In the “framing” condition, participants read a message aimed at increasing feelings of connection to the existing social system, linking the nation’s “way of life” to natural and cultural traditions and communicating that climate change poses a threat that requires patriotic, pro-environmental action to “protect and preserve” the national heritage “as it should be.” The message, which was accompanied by photographs of cities, natural resources, people, and flags, was tailored to include country-specific terms.
Participants in the control and framing conditions were then asked to answer questions pertaining to belief in climate change, support for pro-environmental policies, and willingness to share climate information on social media.
Among US participants, those who read the patriotic/status quo message showed increased belief in climate change, more support for pro-environmental policies, and a greater willingness to share climate information on social media relative to the control group. Moreover, this message was similarly effective for conservatives and liberals.
“Climate change is a challenge that must urgently be tackled,” says Mason.
“Our approach tested the ways to communicate information about climate change that resonates with people’s pre-existing values and beliefs. Crucially, these results suggest that messages aligning with preferences maintaining the status quo may improve climate awareness and action among not only conservatives—whose attitudes are most in sync with such messages—but also among liberals.”
In the paper, the researchers offer a detailed analysis of findings from other nations, outlining similarities and differences from the US sample and possible reasons for them.
More information: Mason, Katherine A., Effects of system-sanctioned framing on climate awareness and environmental action in the United States and beyond, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (2024). DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2405973121 . doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2405973121
Journal information: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
Provided by New York University
Citation : Psychology study offers messaging roadmap for changing attitudes on environmental issues and policies (2024, September 9) retrieved 9 September 2024 from https://phys.org/news/2024-09-psychology-messaging-roadmap-attitudes-environmental.html This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only. Explore further
Study finds liberals and conservatives differ on climate change beliefs—but are relatively united in taking action 19 shares Facebook
Twitter
Email
Feedback to editors
Featured Last Comments Popular Archaeologists discover a likely place for Neanderthal and Homo sapiens interbreeding 9 hours ago
1
New observations shed more light on the nature of a millisecond pulsar binary 10 hours ago
0
Saturday Citations: Teen seals photobomb research site; cell phones are safe; serotonin and emotional resilience Sep 7, 2024
0
Pottery shards provide insight into the lives and trade networks of enslaved people in the Cayman Islands Sep 7, 2024
0
Supramolecular material able to store compressed hydrogen in a way that is not too heavy Sep 6, 2024
0
Pausing biological clock could give boost to lab-produced blood stem cells 2 hours ago
Sweeping global study charts a path forward for climate-resilient agriculture 3 hours ago
Chemical chameleon reveals novel pathway for separating rare-earth metals 3 hours ago
AI boosts indoor food production’s energy sustainability 3 hours ago
Archaeologists challenge theory of violent Steppe invasion in Iberia Peninsula 3 hours ago
Formation of super-Earths proven limited near metal-poor stars 3 hours ago
With AI, extreme microbe reveals how life’s building blocks adapt to high pressure 3 hours ago
Genetic analysis reveals new giant fanged frog species in Philippines that is nearly identical to even larger species 4 hours ago
Unraveling the fundamental principles of eutectic solidification with real-time, nanoscale imaging 4 hours ago
Open-source software helps streamline 2D materials research with scanning tunneling microscope automation 4 hours ago
